Shop local

Thrift stores in Santa Rosa

Santa Rosa has 7 independent thrift stores in this directory. The highest rated by Google rating and review count are Pick of the Litter Thrift and Gift Shop, Ark Thrift Store Donate and Donation Pick Up and Fatty's Threads.

Updated September 2026 · Independent thrift stores in Santa Rosa: 7

7 places

Thrift stores in Santa Rosa: the full list

Best thrift stores in Santa Rosa, 2026

Top 7 by Google rating and review count · Updated September 2026

  1. 1Pick of the Litter Thrift and Gift Shop★★★★☆4.4 · 247 Google reviews
  2. 2Ark Thrift Store Donate and Donation Pick Up★★★★☆4.7 · 133 Google reviews
  3. 3Fatty's Threads★★★★☆4.7 · 83 Google reviews
  4. 4Assistance League Thrift Shop★★★★☆4.4 · 27 Google reviews
  5. 5Intrepid Stores★★★★☆3.9 · 29 Google reviews
  6. 6Heavenly Treasures★★★★☆4.4 · 18 Google reviews
  7. 7Sutter Hospice Thrift Store - Cleveland Ave★★★★☆3.8 · 23 Google reviews
How this ranking works. Each place scores its Google rating × log10 of its review count, so a 4.8 with 2,000 reviews ranks above a 4.8 with 40, and a high rating still counts more than volume alone. Only places with at least 10 reviews are ranked, and only independent businesses in Santa Rosa in this guide are included: no chains, no paid placement. Ratings are Google snapshots checked September 2026 and change over time.

Map of thrift stores in Santa Rosa

Map of 7 places loads as you scroll.

Questions

What are the best thrift stores in Santa Rosa?

Ranked by Google rating weighted by review count: Pick of the Litter Thrift and Gift Shop (4.4, 247 reviews), Ark Thrift Store Donate and Donation Pick Up (4.7, 133 reviews) and Fatty's Threads (4.7, 83 reviews).

How many thrift stores are in Santa Rosa?

7 independent thrift stores are listed for Santa Rosa, including Fatty's Threads, Ark Thrift Store Donate and Donation Pick Up and Pick of the Litter Thrift and Gift Shop.

Which thrift stores in Santa Rosa have the most Google reviews?

Pick of the Litter Thrift and Gift Shop has the most, 247 reviews at 4.4 stars, followed by Ark Thrift Store Donate and Donation Pick Up with 133 and Fatty's Threads with 83.

How many thrift stores in Santa Rosa are rated 4.5 stars or higher?

2 of the 7 with 10 or more Google reviews hold 4.5 stars or higher: Fatty's Threads and Ark Thrift Store Donate and Donation Pick Up.

Santa Rosa AI

Your Santa Rosa local guide
Hey there!

I'm Santa Rosa AI. Ask about local food, shopping, history or a day out.

AI recommendations may be inaccurate. Verify hours and prices. Questions are processed by Cloudflare. Privacy